Under the Greenwood Tree; Or, The Mellstock Quire: A Rural Painting of the Dutch School
Thomas Hardy · Project Gutenberg · Analyzed by Maliang Writer
"Under the Greenwood Tree; Or, The Mellstock Quire" by Thomas Hardy is a novel published in 1872. Set in the fictional village of Mellstock, it follows young Dick Dewy, a member of the traditional parish choir, as he falls for the beautiful new schoolmistress, Fancy Day. When a new vicar threatens to replace the choir's string music with a modern organ, Dick must navigate both the changing times …
This page summarizes our analysis of the book. It does not reproduce the text.
Overview
Pacing at a glance
Pacing pattern:Alternating comic and serious chapters, each serious advance answered by a lighter scene, with dates and seasons carrying the gaps between meetings
Emotional curve:A long trough of obstruction followed by an exposure, a false victory, a second trough and a comic ascent
What works
Chapters 2-6: The vivid depiction of the choir's Christmas Eve rounds creates a rich, atmospheric portrait of rural communal life, with humor and warmth that endears the characters to the reader.
Chapters 14 and 15 turn a parish negotiation into comedy through the choir's ceremonial manners and the vicar's awkward honesty, and they resolve the choir's immediate crisis with a credible compromise.
Chapters 24 and 26 make the social obstacle real through concrete detail (the butcher's bill, the hive fumigation) rather than argument, so the refusal and the yielding both carry weight.
Where it slows down
The preface (Chapter 1) is largely expository and may deter readers expecting a narrative, as it lacks characters and plot, though it provides valuable context.
Chapters 12, 13 and 15 are dense with talk among minor characters, and the distinction between Spinks, Mail, Bowman and Penny blurs, so the reader's attention depends on the tranter alone.
Chapter 22 is almost pure dialogue about dress and appearance, and its only plot work, the plan to visit Geoffrey, is restated in the next chapter.
Story arcs
Arc
Chapters
Climax
The Decline of the Old Church Music
1–7
—
The Mellstock Quire's Displacement
1–15
Ch. 14
The Decline of the Mellstock Quire
1–30
Ch. 27
The Mellstock Quire's Christmas Rounds
2–6
Ch. 5
Dick's Courtship of Fancy Day
4–30
Ch. 28
The Day Family's Consent and the Sham Illness
21–26
Ch. 26
The Vicar's Proposal and Withdrawal
27–29
Ch. 28
Characters
Main characters
Dick DewyProtagonist Young treble violinist of the Mellstock Quire and son of the tranter, who falls in love with the new schoolmistress Fancy Day.
Fancy DayProtagonist The pretty young schoolmistress of Mellstock, daughter of keeper Geoffrey Day, who is courted by Dick, Shiner and the vicar.
Reuben DewySupporting Dick's father, the Mellstock tranter or irregular carrier, host of the quire and a genial, managing man.
William DewySupporting Dick's grandfather, the aged leader of the Mellstock Quire, who plays the bass viol and clings to the old church music.
Mr. MayboldSupporting The young, newly arrived vicar of Mellstock, who resolves to replace the quire with an organ and falls in love with Fancy Day.
Geoffrey DaySupporting Fancy's father, head gamekeeper and timber-steward at Yalbury Wood, a taciturn, close man who opposes Dick as a suitor.
Mr. ShinerAntagonist A wealthy farmer and churchwarden who covets Fancy Day and urges the vicar to replace the quire with an organ.
Michael MailSupporting An elderly, bowed fiddler of the Mellstock Quire, given to caution and long anecdotes.
Robert PennySupporting The Mellstock boot- and shoemaker, a quire member with circular spectacles and a talent for reading feet.
Thomas LeafSupporting A thin, simple-minded young singer of the Mellstock Quire whose high treble the quire depends on.
World
World-building and key terms
Yalbury WoodPlace Woodland forming part of an outlying estate of the Earl of Wessex, crossed by the Casterbridge-to-London highway. Geoffrey Day is its keeper and timber-steward…
MellstockPlace A large rural parish scattered over several hamlets, with Lower Mellstock, Upper Mellstock, the church and vicarage, schoolhouse and outlying farms. The hamlet…
Mellstock ChurchPlace The parish church, whose west gallery is the quire's domain, set apart in status from the nave below. In later chapters an organ is placed in the chancel and t…
SchoolhousePlace The Mellstock school on a slight eminence at the junction of three ways, where Fancy Day lives and teaches. Its upper window becomes the spot from which she fi…
Mellstock QuireFaction The parish church band of string players and singers, led by old William Dewy and including Dick, Reuben, Michael Mail, Penny, Spinks, Bowman and Leaf. They pl…
Budmouth-RegisPlace A seaside town with an Esplanade, a King's statue and hotels, ten or eleven miles from Mellstock. Dick drives there in his cart and brings Fancy home from it, …
OrganItem A cabinet-organ brought to Mellstock by the new vicar, Mr. Maybold, which he intends to have Fancy Day play in place of the old string quire. Its installation …
Yalbury Wood honey-takingEvent Geoffrey Day's honey harvest, when the bees are suffocated in their hives and the honeycomb is cut out. Dick comes to the keeper's house to be seen and judged …
Christmas carol roundsEvent The quire's custom of walking the parish on Christmas Eve to sing carols and hymns at each house and farm, ending at the church gallery for food and drink. Hou…
The tranter's partyEvent A Christmas-season dance at Reuben Dewy's house, where no dancing is allowed until Christmas night is out. Dick dances with Fancy, and the farmers, musicians a…
Yalbury Wood keeper's housePlace Geoffrey Day's isolated cottage, furnished in duplicate pairs of clocks, dressers and Bibles as a marriage provision for Fancy. Its chimney-corner has a chimne…
Grey's WoodPlace A hazel and wooded tract with Snail-Creep path and Cuckoo-Lane, where Dick goes nutting in his vexation and where Fancy wanders searching for him after their q…
Foreshadowing
Foreshadowing and open threads
The quire's displacementOpen The choir fears that barrel-organs and harmoniums are replacing the old string players, and the new vicar's organ and his intention to install Fancy as player …
Dick's attraction to the schoolmistressOpen At the school window the quire sees a beautiful girl who thanks them; Dick is instantly smitten, and the tranter predicts she will wind the young vicar round h…
Shiner's schemingOpen The tranter sees that Shiner wants Fancy shown off in church and is at the root of the vicar's move against the quire. This points to Shiner as a hidden rival …
Geoffrey's promise to ShinerOpen Fancy confesses that her father has told Shiner he would welcome him as a son-in-law and has urged her to encourage him. This raises the obstacle of a father's…
The vicar's love for FancyOpen Mrs. Penny observes the vicar looking at Fancy in a warmer way than Christianity asked for, and the villagers suspect it. This hints at a rival whose proposal …
The secret kept from DickReinforced Fancy accepts the vicar's proposal in a moment of temptation, then withdraws it and begs that the meeting be kept secret. The secret between them raises the qu…
Pacing
Highest-scoring chapters
Every analyzed chapter (30 in total) is scored for tension, information density, emotional intensity and conflict. These are the 15 chapters with the highest overall score.
Ch. 28CHAPTER VI. INTO TEMPTATION · tension 9 Climax On a wet Sunday evening Fancy sits by the school window, weary of living alone and facing months before her wedding. Dick arrives soaked from the funeral, and she sends him away without a real kiss, …
Ch. 17CHAPTER VII. DICK MAKES HIMSELF USEFUL · tension 8.5 Buildup Dick drives Fancy and her goods to her empty schoolhouse and stays to help her settle in. They make tea with one cup, one saucer and one spoon, wash their hands in the same basin, and fall into intim…
Ch. 19CHAPTER I. DRIVING OUT OF BUDMOUTH · tension 7.6 Climax At Budmouth Dick finds Fancy waiting for the carrier and offers her a lift home, which she accepts. Their talk is awkward at first, then Dick asks directly whether she loves him. Fancy resists, calls…
Ch. 21CHAPTER III. A CONFESSION · tension 7.2 Buildup Three months after Budmouth, Fancy tells Susan Dewy she resents Dick dancing with a pretty curly-haired girl at a gipsy party. When Dick arrives, Fancy claims she has sinned by letting Mr. Shiner tea…
Ch. 24CHAPTER II. HONEY-TAKING, AND AFTERWARDS · tension 7.2 Pressure Dick walks to Yalbury and finds Shiner at the honey-taking. Geoffrey, Enoch and the family suffocate bees and take honeycomb, and Geoffrey is stung but stays calm. Fancy stings her lip, and both Dick…
Ch. 29CHAPTER VII. SECOND THOUGHTS · tension 7.8 Release Maybold writes to Yorkshire to arrange an exchange of livings, then walks to Casterbridge to post the letter. On the road he meets Dick, who happily reveals that Fancy is his sweetheart and that they…
Ch. 20CHAPTER II. FURTHER ALONG THE ROAD · tension 6.6 Climax Dick and Fancy drive on and are passed by a gig in which Shiner stares boldly at Fancy. Dick reproaches her for seeming pleased, and she denies it. Dick then tells her that Shiner persuaded the vicar…
Ch. 6CHAPTER V. THE LISTENERS · tension 6.5 Buildup The schoolmistress, Fancy Day, appears at her window and thanks the singers, making a striking impression on Dick and the others. At Farmer Shiner's, the choir is rudely rebuffed but responds by play…
Ch. 7CHAPTER VI. CHRISTMAS MORNING · tension 5.8 Buildup On Christmas morning, Dick is distracted by thoughts of Fancy. The Dewy family prepares for church, with Dick meticulously cleaning his boots. At church, Fancy enters and Dick is captivated. During t…
Ch. 23CHAPTER I. GOING NUTTING · tension 5.9 Buildup Dick arrives for a nutting half-holiday, but Fancy spends the afternoon altering her Sunday dress. As hours pass, Dick grows angry, decides she cares more for admiration than for him, and leaves with…
Ch. 26CHAPTER IV. THE SPELL · tension 5.9 Release Rumours spread that Fancy is pining: no appetite, bread untouched, butter souring. Geoffrey investigates the school, the baker, and Fancy's butcher bill, finding she has barely eaten for a month. Tol…
Ch. 27CHAPTER V. AFTER GAINING HER POINT · tension 6.6 Buildup Dick and Fancy enjoy a happy season, and the day of the Harvest Thanksgiving and the organ's opening approaches. Dick must help carry a dead friend to the grave at Charmley and will miss Fancy's debu…
Ch. 14CHAPTER IV. THE INTERVIEW WITH THE VICAR · tension 4.6 Buildup The choir calls at the vicarage at six o'clock and, after much shuffling and wiping of boots, the tranter, old William and Thomas Leaf are shown into the vicar's study. Reuben asks that the choir be …
Ch. 16CHAPTER VI. YALBURY WOOD AND THE KEEPER’S HOUSE · tension 6.6 Buildup Dick drives to Geoffrey Day's keeper's house in Yalbury Wood to fetch Fancy and her household goods. He takes dinner with the family, where Geoffrey praises Shiner and hints that Fancy knows him well…
Ch. 5CHAPTER IV. GOING THE ROUNDS · tension 5.8 Buildup The choir begins its Christmas Eve rounds, visiting the hamlets of Mellstock and singing carols at various houses. Old William leads the group, and they discuss the declining popularity of string mus…
Contents
Chapter list
CHAPTER II. UNDER THE GREENWOOD TREE
CHAPTER I. MELLSTOCK-LANE
CHAPTER II. THE TRANTER’S
CHAPTER III. THE ASSEMBLED QUIRE
CHAPTER IV. GOING THE ROUNDS
CHAPTER V. THE LISTENERS
CHAPTER VI. CHRISTMAS MORNING
CHAPTER VII. THE TRANTER’S PARTY
CHAPTER VIII. THEY DANCE MORE WILDLY
CHAPTER IX. DICK CALLS AT THE SCHOOL
CHAPTER I. PASSING BY THE SCHOOL
CHAPTER II. A MEETING OF THE QUIRE
CHAPTER III. A TURN IN THE DISCUSSION
CHAPTER IV. THE INTERVIEW WITH THE VICAR
CHAPTER V. RETURNING HOME WARD
CHAPTER VI. YALBURY WOOD AND THE KEEPER’S HOUSE
CHAPTER VII. DICK MAKES HIMSELF USEFUL
CHAPTER VIII. DICK MEETS HIS FATHER
CHAPTER I. DRIVING OUT OF BUDMOUTH
CHAPTER II. FURTHER ALONG THE ROAD
CHAPTER III. A CONFESSION
CHAPTER IV. AN ARRANGEMENT
CHAPTER I. GOING NUTTING
CHAPTER II. HONEY-TAKING, AND AFTERWARDS
CHAPTER III. FANCY IN THE RAIN
CHAPTER IV. THE SPELL
CHAPTER V. AFTER GAINING HER POINT
CHAPTER VI. INTO TEMPTATION
CHAPTER VII. SECOND THOUGHTS
CHAPTER I
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
What is Under the Greenwood Tree; Or, The Mellstock Quire: A Rural Painting of the Dutch School about?
"Under the Greenwood Tree; Or, The Mellstock Quire" by Thomas Hardy is a novel published in 1872. Set in the fictional village of Mellstock, it follows young Dick Dewy, a member of the traditional parish choir, as he falls for the beautiful new schoolmistress, Fancy Day. When a new vicar threatens …
How was Under the Greenwood Tree; Or, The Mellstock Quire: A Rural Painting of the Dutch School analyzed?
Maliang Writer's analysis agents read the book chapter by chapter. They scored 30 chapters for pacing and recorded 10 character profiles and 12 world-building entries. The results are generated automatically and cross-checked.
Where can I read Under the Greenwood Tree; Or, The Mellstock Quire: A Rural Painting of the Dutch School?
The original is published on Project Gutenberg; the link is in the Source section of this page.
Does this page contain the text of the book?
No. It only shows structured analysis: character and setting summaries, chapter titles, pacing scores and one-line chapter summaries.
Maliang Writer runs the same agents on the novel you are writing: characters, world-building, foreshadowing and chapter pacing, kept up to date as you write.